Would you like to make English your default language on this site?


Maghreb reacts to Benghazi attack

By Asmaa Elourfi for Magharebia in Benghazi – 14/09/12

  • 6

The head of Libya's national assembly, Mohammed Magarief, paid respects to slain US ambassador Christopher Stevens during a visit to the American consulate in Benghazi on Friday (September 14th).

Magarief placed a bouquet of flowers in front of the consulate where Stevens died on Tuesday when suspected Islamic militants fired on the compound with rocket-propelled grenades and set it ablaze, AFP reported.

Visibly moved, the president of the General National Congress said he regretted the loss of "a friend of Libyans who rendered laudable services to Libya".

Surrounded by heavy security, Magarief was accompanied by Libya's military chief of staff Yussef al-Mangush.

Libyan mufti Sheikh Al Sadeq Al Gheryani condemned the attack and appealed to people to avoid the provocation of Muslims' feelings through films, pictures or articles denigrating the Prophet Mohammed or any other religious figures.

"We condemn any armed attack by any group operating outside state legitimacy," Al Gheryani said in a written statement. "We remind those people that Prophet Mohammed (PBUH) was the one who criminalised the killing of ambassadors and people who were party to treaties and covenants."

The statement describes the Benghazi attack as "condemnable, a serious indicator of security chaos and a challenge to state authority by the force of arms that is rejected and condemned by all Libyans who love their country, all wise people and those who carry the name of Islam".

"This is an irresponsible act that neither defends Islam nor serves its purposes; rather, it severely harms the country's high interests by provoking other nations, prompting them to classify it on the list of terrorism in order to intervene in its affairs and violate its sovereignty and sanctities," Al Gheryani wrote. "It also seriously harms Islam."

Libyans on Friday continued their demonstrations of protest of the attacks, and to mourn the loss of Ambassador Stevens, who was viewed by many as a friend of Libya. Such demonstrations continued online, on numerous Facebook pages such as one rallying readers under the theme "Terrorism does not represent me".

One visitor to the page, Sasa Anies, wrote: "Do not kill and burn in the name of Islam. Question for those who burnt the consulate and killed the ambassador: where was the hospitality and positivity in the name of Islam and the Prophet in what you did? If the Prophet were here among us, would he bless your actions? You should have gone instead to the internet to introduce our prophets."

Magharebia spoke to a number of Benghazi residents to learn their reactions to the tragedy.

"Were they truly members of Ansar al-Sharia?" asked Fatma Majed. "Is the storming of consulate and killing of ambassador a solution to defend God's Prophet? Did our Prophet ask us to resort to terrorism? Is this the way to defend our Prophet? You're a terrorist group led by the cohorts of the buried [Kadhafi], as this is not a way for understanding and dialogue."

"I offer my condolences and sorrow," said Hakem El Monafy. "I strongly condemn this heinous crime against unarmed innocent nationals of the US, a friendly country that supported us and condemned the acts of the tyrant at the time of war against his brigades. Those friends who are working in the US consulate are innocent and human beings who have nothing to do with any denigration of our religious beliefs."

These sentiments were echoed throughout the Maghreb.

Mauritanian scholar Sheikh Abdullah Bin Bayyah, Director of Attajdid Wal Tarsheed Center and Deputy Secretary-General of the Union of Muslim Scholars, reacted to the attack on Wednesday. "Assaulting innocent people and killing diplomats and ambassadors is a breach of religion before it is of politics," he said.

At the same time, he called "on wise people around the world to carefully reflect on the consequences and tragic effects of provoking the feelings of more than 1 billion people by a group that doesn’t want to see peace on earth or harmony among people".

Mohammed Salem Ould Sheikh, editor of douroub.info, said, "We as Muslims should defend the Prophet but using the Prophet's manners that condemn violence and respond to ideas with ideas and arguments with arguments."

He added: "I'm personally against the killing of the US ambassador or anyone else for their ideas or opinions, especially as that ambassador had nothing to do with the film. This sort of behaviour just increases the film's publicity."

In Algeria the streets were calm. There were no calls for demonstrations from political parties or other associations, but security was reportedly stepped up at the US Embassy in Algiers.

"The attack on the American Consulate in Benghazi is an unspeakable event," Algerian foreign affairs spokesman Amar Belani told reporters on Wednesday. "It goes against the laws of all religions, and violates the principle of the sanctity of diplomatic premises."

"Algeria equally deplores the irresponsibility of those who made the film 'Innocence of Muslims'," he added, "which is offensive to Islam and the Prophet, peace be upon him."

Foreign Minister Mourad Medelci sent a message of sympathy to his American counterpart, US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

The Moroccan government "presented its sincere condolences to the American government and people".

Mustapha El Khalfi, the communications minister and government spokesman, reaffirmed the government's commitment to the values of peace, tolerance and cooperation. "People have a guaranteed right to peaceful demonstration, but not to call for or support violence," he told the government council on Thursday.

"Muslims across the world have the right to express their views on the [film], but not by resorting to violence," Rabat resident Chourouk Senhaji told Magharebia. "Only extremists could resort to this act of terrorism."

"If we use force we shall lose everything," said Mustapha Benhamza, chairman of the local council of Ulemas in Oujda. "We must not fall into that trap."

Siham Ali in Rabat, Fidet Mansour in Algiers and Jemal Oumar in Nouakchott contributed to this report.

What do you think of this article?


Subscribe to our newsletter and get Magharebia's latest articles delivered to your inbox.


Anonymous thumb

You are not signed in. Anonymous comments are subject to moderation. Sign up to have your comment posted immediately - Learn more

Or post your comment using:


  1. Anonymous thumb

    younsi djamel 2012-10-4

    Mustapha El Khalfi said, “The people have a guaranteed right to peaceful protest, but not to call for or support violence.” What is this? You have the right to demonstrate to say this and that, but you do not have the right to demonstrate to say that and this! That is called making the people stand at attention for you.


  2. Anonymous thumb

    younsi djamel ben youcef ben Mezne 2012-10-4

    This American ambassador “was known for his fairness and love for Libyans”!? Whatever! Know that there are no non-Muslim Americans who love a Muslim! All the Jewish and Christian Americans love Israel and are for Israel and against all of the Muslim countries! You see this every day in the American Senate, when it votes in a law in favour of Israel against all of the Muslims! I dare you to show me the opposite!


  3. Anonymous thumb

    sidi 2012-9-29

    All Muslims who know the rules and verses of our holy religion would avoid killing an insect that is not waging war on Islam. But, these terrorist groups are not true mujaheddins of Islam. They massacre anyone who is not of their opinion. But the Western countries hold a large part of the responsibility in these crimes. They are closing their eyes and mouths when these satans – these false Muslims – attack other countries that do not protect their interests. A terrorist is still a terrorist no matter his alliances.


  4. Anonymous thumb

    خميسي 2012-9-16

    Why don’t we support our dear messenger?


  5. Anonymous thumb

    BEN 2012-9-15

    What is the truth in all of this? It is not politically correct to say this if you put yourself on the side of the US elections, but the US legal system itself could, if it wanted, clear things up for the international community regarding this call for violence and the murders spurred by this so-called "film", which is not at all a film except in that it has "rogue" images from an anonymous, dubious intermediary, who was on the verge of criminality via modern media. We now know the people who helped him “succeed”. But, Islam has nothing to do with this Mein Kampf and its followers, who are in a party with dangerous lobbies and who would gain a lot in getting themselves forgotten.


  6. Anonymous thumb

    آل يوسف الإدريسي 2012-9-14

    The proverb says “who will feel you, o bee on the corn of the bull?” This means that if this individual had not denigrated the prophet, he wouldn’t have become famous and nobody would have tried to know what he presents. If we replied instead that we sanctify our master Jesus more than any Christian who believes in our master Jesus and that the followers of our master Jesus humiliated him by showing him crucified, subjugated and subservient but we Muslims believe that our master Jesus was elevated by God to Him, that we pray for the blessings of all prophets of God and messengers as we sanctify our master Mohammed, peace and blessings of God be upon him. We won’t accept that anyone says anything bad about him, no matter who he is. However, if only angry irritated people hadn’t kill innocent people including the American ambassador who was known for his fairness and love for Libyans! The staff of the embassy have nothing to do with the cursed movie. If we learnt that Zionism is in charge of making the film, if we knew that the film coincided with the painful events of September 9, if we knew that events of September 9 were planned by Zionists who infiltrated the Ben Laden organisation. They funded the operation as they did fund the production of the film denigrating the messenger, peace and blessings of God be upon him, if we knew all this, we would be careful and cautious instead of killing innocent people and thus appear in the eyes the world as barbarians who rise up legitimately but kill treacherously. The current conflict is a masonry-Zionist/Muslim conflict.