2012-01-10
Tunisian rights groups oppose al-Mahmoudi extradition
By Monia Ghanmi for Magharebia in Tunis – 10/01/12
Fifteen Tunisian and international human rights groups issued a joint statement Saturday (January 7th) calling on the Tunisian government not to extradite former Libyan Prime Minister al-Baghdadi Ali al-Mahmoudi.
The statement followed a press conference organised by the Tunisian branch of Amnesty International and the Tunisian Association for Combating Torture (ALTT) on Friday where activists claimed that the extradition of the Kadhafi regime official would expose him to risk of torture or extrajudicial execution in violation of international agreements signed by Tunisia.
"We ask the president of the republic not to authorise the extradition to the new Libyan authorities if they do not guarantee a fair trial," Sondes Garbouj, the president of Amnesty International in Tunisia, told the news conference.
President Moncef Marzouki said last week during his trip to Libya that Tunisia was waiting on guarantees of a fair trial and assurances that al-Mahmoudi would not be harmed before any extradition. He noted that Tunisia itself was seeking the extradition of deposed President Zine El Abidine Ben Ali from Saudi Arabia.
"We refuse the extradition of Mr al-Mahmoudi so long as the death penalty still exists in Libya. The new Tunisia cannot extradite a person threatened with execution," AFP quoted ALTT head Radhia Nasraoui as saying.
Habib Marsit, head of the Tunisian National Coalition for Abolition of the Death Penalty, echoed the concern, noting that the Libyan judiciary still used capital punishment.
Following Marzouki's visit to Libya, the activists expressed concern that al-Mahmoudi would be extradited to Tripoli as part of improved ties between Tunisian authorities and their Libyan counterparts.
"We reject employment in exchange for extradition," Nasraoui said. "In addition, our traditions don't allow the extradition of someone who sought our help and resorted to us."
Béchir Essid, a lawyer for al-Mahmoudi, said that article 313 in the Tunisian penal code bans the extradition of detainees in case the arrest warrant carries a political nature, a condition he believes applies to al-Mahmoudi.
"The necessary conditions for a fair trial for any wanted individual in Libya are not available now because the political and judicial conditions in that brotherly country are not stable now," he added. "The new rulers in Libya want to have him extradited because they simply want to liquidate him like they did with the rest of former regime officials."
Essid said al-Baghdadi's file was resolved when Tunisia's former interim President Foued Mebazza said before stepping down that he wouldn't sign the extradition decision and stressed the need to release al-Mahmoudi from prison and decide his case once and for all.
Essid noted that al-Mahmoudi didn't seek asylum in Tunisia; rather, he was on his way to Algeria when he was arrested by Tunisian authorities on charges of entering the country illegally.
"What does the Tunisian authority have to do with that so as to place itself in this impasse?" he wondered.
Another lawyer on the al-Mahmoudi defence team, Mabrouk Kourchid, has said that President Marzouki shouldn't talk about extradition while the Libyan government is unable to control violence on its own soil or guarantee a fair trial.
The former Libyan premier is wanted in his homeland on charges of corruption and other crimes allegedly committed during the Kadhafi regime.
Subscribe to our newsletter and get Magharebia's latest articles delivered to your inbox.

![[AFP/ Hrvoje Polan] A group of Tunisian rights defenders mounted a campaign against handing over former Libyan PM al-Baghdadi Ali al-Mahmoudi to the NTC.](/awi/images/2012/01/10/120110Feature1Photo1-271_179.jpg)
POST YOUR COMMENT 5
2012-5-28
To El hadi. Everything is easy o rat! If brothers in Tunisia refused to extradite al-Mahmudi, bring NATO against them as it is your guardian, ally and lover “showing affection towards them”. You can even destroy with it our country Algeria. Your retaliation council has previously threatened the Algerian government, even before Kadhafi was toppled!!! The picture is very, very, very clear: a bunch of rats threatening Algeria (Algeria = Libya x5!!!) The answer is clear: rats boast of NATO and crusaders. They have become one family. Moreover, you, hypocrite, are talking about your valiant master Moamar Kadhafi. All free people in the world know the value of Kadhafi. O agent, o seller of your honor, religion and homeland! Moamar is noble. This is confirmed by the fact that Gulf pigs and crusaders made an alliance against him. Kadhafi is one of the greatest leaders in the modern history of the third world (in spite of some of his mistakes, shortcomings. No one is perfect among humans except prophets!) Don’t forget that you were intentionally hindering and sabotaging the policy of Kadhafi. Now you blame everything on him! You ignite fire and you ask where smoke comes from!!
0 Likes
Anonymous 2012-5-27
If Ben Ali were in Libya, Libyans wouldn’t have extradited him. I call upon the Tunisian government to reconsider this issue.
0 Likes
مختار 2012-1-11
What would this Radhia Nasraoui have done if she were raped with the orders of the corrupt Al-Baghdadi, would she defend him or not unless she is one of the supporters and advocates of rape??
0 Likes
lemarocain 2012-1-10
Perhaps these human rights groups have not felt the pain of their loved ones losing their lives under the dictator Kadhafi. In reality, the NGOs that defend these dictators who led fallen countries under the dictators’ boots like poodles are also common criminals. I think that these NGOs do not care about healing the pains of these loved ones, of these tortured, thirsty, starving and so on citizens. They try to defend the bloodthirsty evildoers. These NGOs should take a good look at the way they marginalise the citizens and put themselves in their shoes.
0 Likes
El hadi 2012-1-10
Ennahda’s Tunisia must absolutely return the traitor Mahmoudi to the Libyan CNT authorities; otherwise, the North Africans will grow sick with the current wait-and-see attitude of the new Tunisia, which will be guilty of the same crime as Ben Ali’s old regime! Libya, freed from the criminal Kadhafi, must interrogate Mahmoudi on the assassination of Moussa Sadr, on the disappearances of the Libyan and foreign opponents in Libya, on the secret actions of Kadhafi and his henchmen, on Libya’s secrete fortunes abroad and, likewise, on the many sordid schemes of the former regime had with the neighbouring countries. Tunisia, on the other hand, is free to demand a normal trial that guarantees the rights of the traitor Mahmoudi. What would Tunisia say if Ben Ali were taking refuge in Libya and Libya were dragging its feet to return him to Tunisia!?! This would also make us fed up!
0 Likes